Have you ever hacked a product to do something it wasn't intended to do in order to "simplify" things for your users and have that blow up in your face? This is an account of my experiences doing just that with MS Reporting Services.
If you've used Reporting Services at all, you'll know that there are two virtual directories that are created on IIS when you first install it to a server: ReportServer actually serves up the reports by passing the requested data to external applications via whatever protocol you have configured and Reports (aka ReportManager) which serves as a user interface for reports on the server.
ReportManager is, by far, the most visible of the two. Using ReportManager, you can organize your reports and data sources and set permissions on who can view and change them. Often, this is enough of a user interface that it is a viable deployment mechanism to simply point your users to the Url for a report under the ReportManager directory.
Ingenious people, like myself, will often designate a new Web instance on IIS just for Reporting Services, generally naming it something clever like "reports". When you do this, it is very tempting to point the root directory of that web instance to the ReportManager directory. This means that you can point your users to "http://reports/Invoice" instead of "http://reports/Reports/Invoice". You can see why you'd want to make this change (assuming you are similarly obsessive).
There is, however, an unintended side-effect to this change. Once you do this, your ReportServer will begin throwing errors if you ever decide you want to use direct Url access to display reports. Not a lot of people do this unless they're using a Reporting Services "Integration" that uses this functionality for showing reports. Personally, I ran into this situation when trying to tie our Reporting Services forms into Great Plains. Since Great Plains integrations (both native and third party) expect to use ReportServer for the report display, I was shocked and dismayed to find myself staring at this error:
The type Microsoft.ReportingServices.UI.WebControlConnection, ReportingServicesWebUserInterface, Version=188.8.131.52, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=89845dcd8080cc91 does not implement IReportServerConnection or could not be found
Hitting Google for this error is more than a little bit frustrating because the vast majority of issues where it shows up is in mis-configuring a ReportViewer object in an ASP.Net web application. This is manifestly not the case here.
This was a dome-scratcher for a lot longer than I like to admit. All of the advice pieces that I could find for this error are simply inapplicable. Fortunately, I ran across a Usenet post by Dave Green from last July. Dave reported that he could fix ReportServer if he removed a couple of settings from the <appSettings> section of the ReportManager. This is most odd because the two simply shouldn't be linked--at least, in that direction. If they were linked, I'd expect that link to go the other way (i.e. something in ReportServer breaking ReportManager). After all, ReportManager is essentially a UI on top of ReportServer.
I tested his findings and sure enough, removing the appSettings fixed ReportServer for me. Since removing those settings broke ReportManager, this was an unappetizing solution.
It was then that I remembered that IIS does an interesting little trick with web.config files and subdirectories. You see, each subdirectory on a website inherits the configuration from parent directories (also machine.config, but that's not relevant to our story). It doesn't matter how those directories are physically arranged, what is important is that IIS uses the Url to determine inheritance. So in a situation where "http://reports" is pointing at ReportManager and "http://reports/ReportServer" is pointing to ReportServer, that means that ReportServer is inheriting the web.config settings from ReportManager. Thus, the appSettings for ReportManager are being read by ReportServer and misapplied (I've no idea why the presence of an appSettings entry would break ReportServer)
Fortunately, the fix for this issue is pretty simple. The <appSettings> element includes a spec for a clear directive that will wipe out all inherited values. Adding an appropriate entry to the web.config in ReportServer cleared the problem right up. Here's the section for the curious (and/or lazy):
So there you go. I hoisted myself by my own petard. Fortunately, I was able to figure out how to get myself unhoisted. I now have both ReportManager and ReportServer humming along nicely without having to undo my clever directory mapping. Since I haven't been able to find this solution anywhere, I figured I'd post this for those in similar situations.
Technorati tags: ReportingServices